Home » essay » sitizenship education dissertation

Sitizenship education dissertation


In this composition, I will argue that it is impossible to establish trans-national citizenship and i also will make this argument regarding European nationality. There are primarily five factors supporting my personal argument. To begin with, as education exerts a fantastic influence within the establishment of European nationality, it is necessary to identify the current position of the education for Western citizenship and investigate if these educational activities will be of help to its business. Education for European citizenship is so significant as European citizenship is not really a shared ethnic heritage that Europeans can automatically identify themselves to.

Rather, it really is established on such basis as a distributed democratic culture that Europeans recognize themselves as residents of European countries. Therefore , for young people in Europe, educational initiatives are of great importance in facilitating the process of creating European citizenship. These educational actions have been carried out in a large number of areas such as terminology, history to be able to enhance and promote their sense of belonging to European countries, which contributes to the business as well as the progress European nationality.

Regarding this, many efforts have been made to accomplish this objective, the details which are contained in the body part, however , it remains ambiguous that simply how much it has been carried out and whether it be effective or not.

Hence the work that have already been made seem not to help the organization nor motivate the development of Euro citizenship. Secondly, according to Sobisch(1997), there are three explanations presented in order to meet the requirements of the establishment of European citizenship. They can be “political-legal, civic-virtue and Western identity” (Sobisch, 1997, s. 74). Because of the failure in order to meet the last two requirements, the potential of European nationality is minimal. The definition of “civic virtue” (Sobisch, 1997) signifies the normative element of European citizenship, which refers to those good qualities of individuals. But there is certainly almost no materials that can be followed to have noted the specific obligations or commitments connected to Western citizenship, neither there are many possibilities for Europeans to perform their particular duties inside the context of transnational concept-Europe, which means that the “good features of citizens” are generally not specifically governed in any relevant literature. With regard to the facet of European personality, evidence is provided in your body part.

Thirdly, it is apparent that the reputation of the similarity in nationalities and values is vital to determine EU nationality just as Jean Monnet says “If we were beginning the European community all over again, we ought to begin with culture” (as cited in Schlesinger, 1987, l. 222). Because there exists profound diversity in both cultures and ideals within the Europe, it slows the process of the development of European citizenship to some extent. In Eder and Giesen’s theory, “collective identity” (Eder & Giesen, 2003) comprises the foundation of the creation of Western citizenship. As a result of reason there is no family member common ethnic heritage that is certainly considered as a crucial element intended for establishing communautaire identity is available after all, through looking back into the Western history, consequently , there is a deficiency of solid foundation inside the establishment of European citizenship as the regular shared ethnic heritage is really little. Fourthly, the support of the general public plays an essential part in the establishment of European nationality.

When Western european citizenship was included in Maastricht Treaty, various debates asked its efficiency, to be further, the benefits it could bring out to European open public and the legal rights it can scholarhip citizens as its establishment. With regard to this, Eu has striven to take several effective actions to attain this kind of goal. “These have included the creation of such ‘special rights’ as the enfranchisement of EU nationals in regional elections their current address, rather than wherever they keep citizenship; the creation of EU passports; and a common area of free movement for individuals (“Schengen and that”) and with goods” (Weiner, 1998, g. 603). Sadly, the possibilities plus the opportunities as well as the rights mentioned in the treaty and other documentations have not been taken into action, or any are useless, thus discouraging the public.

As the support of the public provides a stable grounding for the readiness to establish Western european citizenship, the proposal falls flat at this point. Finally, the integration of European society is closely related to building European nationality. The reasons why it is essential to the starting of it happen to be listed. After that three factors are protected to present the fact that there is a bleak way forward for the integration of European world due to the superb divergence in European countries. Consequently , it is not hard to infer that the organization of European citizenship is not in prospect.


Precisely what is meant by citizenship in the context of not one single country but some countries has to be defined at the very beginning as it is crucial and fundamental when contemplating the possibility or impossibility of a particular type of trans-national nationality. Eder&Giesen(2003) gave the definition of European nationality: “European citizenship emerges like a concept that thematizes the situation of the interpersonal integration of Europe. Western citizenship fulfills- like any additional citizenship- two functions: to get a social basis for transnational institutions and define precisely what is shared simply by those contained in the social space covered by Western institutions”(p. 2). Dell’olio(2005) offered the definition coming from another point of view: “It takes place with the formation of a supra-national community. Conceptually, citizenship now becomes separate from the nation-state in that the rights associated with citizenship can be also governed and assured by supra-national institutions” (p. 23 ). Sobisch (1997) put the explanation this way:

Provided the double entendre surrounding the term European nationality, it is probably best defined ex desfavorable, that is, by what it is not. To start with, the Treaty of Eu does not set up a nationality with the Union, but rather a contributory citizenship to this of a member state. Secondly, the privileges granted by Treaty of European Union are not only limited in scope, they are also highly qualified. The rights would be the right to cost-free movement, the right of house and so on. There are seven privileges that are approved to the people proudly owning the nationality of the affiliate states. (p. 82)

From this essay, the European nationality is assumed to be a feeling of belonging, a type of personality that Europeans are willing to recognize themselves to. Social incorporation is identified by Sobisch& Immerfall (1997) as “the condition in which will individuals are connected to each other and embedded in the society in particular through increased levels of interdependence, communication, cooperation, and problem solving” (p. 143). 1 ) Education projects that are delivered to establish Western citizenship happen to be ineffective It’s unquestionable that educational actions will be required in order to build and develop European citizenship. There are a large number of educational initiatives which can be designed and carried out by transnational agencies and projects produced by agencies which seek to facilitate the recognition as well as the enhancement of the basics of the Western citizenship between young technology in The european union. Some primary approaches which in turn intend to accomplish this goal are listed as below. Initial, the European Union provides enforced several programmes to achieve this aim and these kinds of will be accomplished in 3 chapters. ERASMUS, for instance, is built to encourage transnational cooperation among universities plus the mobility of students. The 2nd chapter aims at the strengthening of multilateral school cooperations as well as the development of the capability of skills among the list of educational personnel. The third section is related to languages, open and distance learning, mature education, exchanges of information, study visits pertaining to decision makers, and identification of academic skills. As Revealed (1997) explained that:

It is necessary to note the fact that main goals seem to be to build up the Euro dimension rather than education to get citizenship. You can also get two inquiries remain: what lengths is the Eu interested in education for citizenship; and even if it is so interested, how much self-confidence may we have that the programmes outlined previously mentioned are likely to be effective? In addition , these mentioned educational actions will not necessarily translate into action for education intended for citizenship. There seems to be three main overlapping forms of activity: language learning; investigation into a common cultural traditions; and the organizations of relationships between colleges which could come up through work in the popular curriculum or in away of class contexts. (p. 112)

With regard to the political areas of Europe, there is certainly little interest. Therefore , not simply the aspires of a few educational actions are deviated from citizenship education, yet also the results they will bring out consider be not too effective, which suggests that the complex preparation to get the formation of European nationality of the the younger generation is not occurring. This signifies that although the educational actions have been put forward and carried out, they turn out to be of little help to the business of Western citizenship. While education creates a critical importance to the business of Euro citizenship, this scenario failed. installment payments on your The inability to meet the requirements of establishing Western european citizenship installment payments on your 1 The first need is “civic virtue”

Through the perspective with the three natures of Western european citizenship, it seems infeasible for the organization of this type of citizenship. In the nature of “civic-virtue” (Sobisch, 1997) meaning the ordre aspect of European citizenship, is just about the weakest. To elaborate the normative facet of European citizenship, it should be related to the concept of nationality first. In respect to Sobisch, he offered the definition of citizenship based upon the “functional criteria” (Sobisch, 1997). You will discover mainly 3 distinct applications: “political-legal, normative and psychological” (Sobisch, 1997). Sobisch (1997) also says that “it makes sense to revisit the classificatory structure to see how European citizenship fits into it”. (p. 85) Citizenship in the normative perception refers to these personal features which are linked to a “good citizen”. Also, when involves European citizenship, the normative aspect means those personal qualities which are associated with a “good citizen”(Sobisch, 1997). Hence at this particular point, you will discover non-e particular duties will be included and listed by the Maastricht Treaty, not to mention the scarcity of opportunities pertaining to Europeans to launch their civic commitments in the framework of the Union.

Unlike the individual state, there is no Union-wide armed forces service, neither are there any laws and regulations, including tax laws, that apply directly to individuals. (Sobisch, 1997, l. 86) Therefore, it is challenging for Euro citizens to carry out their duties. Moreover, there are very few volume of Europe-wide charity they can add their period as well as money to. Last but not least, it is rather difficult for them to become a “good European” as the meaning requires. installment payments on your 2 The 2nd requirement is related to psychological qualifying criterion Apart from the characteristics of “civic virtue” (Sobisch, 1997), there is certainly another characteristics that can function as the criteria to get the examination of the possibility of Euro citizenship, that is certainly European identity. This qualifying criterion is similar to that of “civic virtue” (Sobisch, 1997) on the European nationality side and “normative” trait at the citizenship side. Seeing that there is serious issue of feasibility in performing Euro citizenship, it is not hard to discern the impossibility of its organization after all.

Euro identity, which is related to the “psychological” criterion of nationality, is hard to accomplish and up to the current, there is data showing that many Europeans do not identify themselves to this. The reason is what Scully (1997) pointed out that “the evolving group of compromises possess advanced Western unity hesitantly, and for example, created in the institutions from the European community a rather uncomfortable structure with which all governments have been able to live, but in which non-e can rejoice” (p. 68). Therefore , many European individuals find europe confusing to them, in fact it is so hard to allow them to identify themselves with that. The fact is that although the Euro citizens will be enjoying the benefits and legal rights European citizenship has brought to them, although not celebrate carefully of this kind of citizenship.

The situation of the creation of Western identity is usually related to the diversity in cultures and values through out European countries which will be mentioned in the third debate. From the two criteria above, it can be concluded that European citizenship fails to meet the requirements. As a result the establishment of it happens to be impossible. 3. Diversity in cultures and values amongst European countries slows the process of developing European nationality

3. 1 Eder and Giesen’s “collective identity” theory

In regard to the diversity that already is present in cultures as well as principles of the member states, a major problem associated with this factor occurs, that is certainly, what is the inspiration of the Western european citizenship. Eder and Giesen (2003) highlights that “in order to give legitimacy towards the particular passions of the Europeans, a post-national collective identity would be necessary to found a European citizenship”. (p. 3) The post-national group identity is critical in that Cerutti argued that (as offered in Deflem and Pample, 1996, g. 121) “as the raising globalization of communication and economic exchanging generates a decrease of well-liked interests in national concerns in favor of an increasing identification with issues over and above national region, the breakthrough of collective identity inside the European Community would reinforce this general trend to post-national identity”.

3. two How theory of “collective identity” pertains to divergence in cultures among

European countries The concept of collective identification consists of several crucial factors, such as the notion of a prevalent cultural traditions. Throwing head back to the history of the complete Europe, wars between nations out of interests are generally not difficult to be aware. It is also a hardcore task to discover a usa combat against foreign attack. Some could argue that Christianity and Renaissance or Enlightenment would be considered to have made a few efforts to provide some form of basis for the normal European ethnic heritage. Require movements are generally not unanimously authorized to be a Euro cultural objective. “The only reference which in turn comes close to a common collective memory of Europeans is perhaps the defeat of Nazism and fascism although even this is occasionally contested” ( Eder& Giesen, 2003, p. 11). Hence, to sum up, there rarely exists the so-called “common cultural heritage” for the Europeans.

It can be concluded that from this aspect, the establishment of European nationality seems to be difficult. 4. The lack of public support impedes the process of building Western citizenship The void of the actual capabilities of the Euro citizenship in addition to the rights it could confer in people arrive to the fore when referring to the possibility of the establishment of European nationality. European citizenship claims to provide people with various possibilities in some arenas of their daily life, just like social and political privileges. Although the choices seem very alluring and encapsulate the purpose of improving householder’s life to a certain degree, several possibilities it has mentioned have never been used into actions yet and some, though having been implemented, lead to disappointing benefits. Therefore , it is devoid of open public support which in turn serves as a significant as well as an indispensable role in the establishment of European citizenship.

4. you citizen’s political rights

In the perspective of citizen’s personal rights that are considered to be a vital part of citizenship within the European Union, it turns out that they will be not always guaranteed to the same extent throughout the European Union. As Dell’olio (2005) pointed out that Both the treaties and more lately the European Union draft constitution provide for “derogations”. Inside the Spanish elections which happened on twenty eight May 1994, only individuals of the Eu coming from the Netherlands, Denmark and Sweden were able to political election according to Royal Rule 202/9, depending on a requirements of reciprocity. This action of Spanish Rule therefore discriminated against individuals of various other European Union countries resident vacation on the grounds of nationality. (p. 78)

It can be discerned that the rule of derogation undermines the equality of citizen’s rights of the affiliate states a fundamental component of political privileges as it offers taken discriminatory measures to smooth the the political election. What’s more serious, instead of intending to create more positive expressions of your supra-national citizenship, it could lead to resentment. Therefore , there is insufficient public help in the process of the establishment with the European nationality. 4. 2 European Union’s incapability of solving open public problems In addition, the lack of general public support could be also seen in terms of European Union’s incapability of solving complications for the population. First of all, the health of unemployment remains severe and not solved.

It includes aroused the public’s discontentment. In addition , while Dell’olio (2005) stated that “the intro of a state-resembling normative institution such as Western citizenship offers nevertheless failed to achieve the aim that greater democratic change of EUROPEAN institutions and more participation in them is going to generate a deeper sense of political community” (p. 80) 4. 3 The disappointment that the European community left to a lot of people Another example is the disappointment the fact that European community left to numerous people. Scully(1997) stated that: By the 1980s, the Euro Community was an established element of European life. While it caused increases in trade, and institutionalised cooperation between it is members, it absolutely was clearly a considerable ways from an in depth federal union. National governments insisted in retaining a veto above many procedures, while the most well-known of those guidelines, the Common Gardening Policy, was becoming a disaster, with great over-production of food bringing about European “food mountains” as well as the destruction of surpluses, every at extensive public price. (p. 56)

From the 3 aspects as stated above, the organization as well as the progress European citizenship are lacking in public places support which in turn indeed leads to as an indispensable factor in the process. 5. The infeasibility of Western social the use results in the impossibility of building European nationality Lastly, associated with European citizenship is connected closely while using integration from the European contemporary society. Therefore it is simple to infer that if the incorporation of the Western society is unsuccessful, after that there is little possibility to get the institution of Western european citizenship. your five. 1 Why social integration is significant for Western european citizenship The reasons why social incorporation is so significant for European citizenship will be the following: in the first place, from the perspective of history, during the past, the state contractor would not love the heterogeneity of the locations that this individual has already considered control of, about condition the fact that heterogeneity would not pose a threat to his domination, however , this is not the case with today’s political context(Sobisch&Immerfall, 1997, p. 143).

The fact is it is almost impossible to transport along the technique of integration with out popular consent. In a normative sense, since Sobisch&Immerfall(1997) explain that “Europe today can be, after all, democratic”(p. 143). Second, in order to encourage the effort between government authorities and improve the possibility of creating a supra-national institution, which is at this point referred to as European citizenship from this essay, prevalent interests are extremely crucial. Areas of social integrations consist of political, economic, and social characteristics, and these elements are the catalyst for the creation of common interests. “The persistence of interpersonal and economical inequality across member says will make that much more hard to create a ‘Social Europe’ based upon the theory of interpersonal solidarity”(Sobisch&Immerfall, 97, p. 143). To explain this relation, an illustration can be taken.

The countries which are richer within Europe would be reluctant to interact personally with the countries that are relatively poorer while the financially prosperous kinds will have the feeling that they can gain no advantages from the co-operation, whereby limiting the process of building a social The european union. Moreover, with regards to party systems which are influenced by sociable and financial inequalities, the establishment of the real Western party program therefore was impeded. Overall economy status of member declares can apply a great influence in many elements, such as worth systems in the areas of personal freedom, morality and so on, hence making it hard to reach a consensus coping with these issues inside the policy making at Euro level. your five. 2 Curve in European societies results in difficulty in achieving sociable integration Then several areas will be included to present the divergence in European communities. It is certain that the divergence results in the problem in attaining social the usage of Euro society, where undermining the prospects with the building of European citizenship.

The first area stated is politics structure. With regards to the thinking to “the welfare state”, which is also known as the “social market economy”, a large number of research have established the existence of marked dissimilarities among societies. The curve in this particular aspect leads to a strong challenge over cultural as well as other policies at the Western european level. The next area is”social stratification”. Social stratification primarily consists of two parts, that may be, economic and financial performance along with family principles. In terms of economic and fiscal performance, there exists great divergence among the list of countries. “Countries like Athens, Denmark, Sweden or Swiss have performed well, although countries like Greece, Spain or The country of spain, have been frequently relegated for the periphery” (Sobisch&Immerfall, 1997, g. 149). Consequently , it can be noted that wonderful difference is present still in the economic circumstances, likewise, the caliber of life, is likewise divergent. When family benefit is concerned, differences in family habits occurs. For example, on the issue of male or female roles, a statement that a woman’s place reaches home, arouses substantial dissimilarities among the Countries in europe. This curve may lead to disagreement in interpersonal and friends and family policy the moment decisions are created at the Western level.

your five. 3 Wonderful uncertainty in possibility of establishing a distributed community brings about difficulty in attaining social integration Overall, there exists great doubt regarding the chance of establishing a shared community in European people’s head. Several elements may contribute to this infeasibility. First of all, while Sobisch&Immerfall(1997) pointed out that “a trans-national European community is missing, where talks between intellectuals still take place mostly within the confines of national philosophical traditions” (p. 158) In addition to this, “no genuinely European get together system has become established yet”(p. 156). Although there are some transnational political groupings that exist, “they are not steady and it is unproductive in creating significant backlinks between d�cider voice and MEP patterns because of their heterogeneity” (p. 158). In addition , since Sobisch and Immerfall (1997) argue that “democratic accountability in the world of mass communication is usually lacking because of the multi-level decision system of the European polity” (p. 158). Taking the current status of the public judgment in The european countries society into consideration, which is designed not very well, whereby it is hard to form a common European general public opinion in the end. From what is presented previously mentioned, it is not difficult to note that the important elements that consist of Western social integration do not add up to a clear movements toward the process of integration in the European culture.


To sum up, first of all, although the educational initiatives which in turn play a crucial role at the same time of the establishment of European citizenship have already been carefully designed and performed, the effects appear not to become very significant. Secondly, according to the three naturel of Western citizenship, the establishment of European nationality does not match the two from the criteria pointed out. Thirdly, for the range that exists in nationalities as well as beliefs in Europeans, and the communautaire identity which is based on the cultures and values, there is certainly almost no relevant literature that features the common shared cultural history among Euro people.

Fourthly, in terms of open public support, which is believed to be the solid grounding of the establishment of Euro citizenship, the failure to make the possibilities which it claims to provide come true and lots of compromises in citizen’s personal rights and also the misconduct with the European Community in the early years disappoint the public and therefore lacking the support of them. Last but not the least, through the perspective of the integration with the European world which is strongly associated with the building of Western citizenship, three areas are covered to illustrate that due to the presence of great divergence in Western european society, there is little probability of the cultural integration of European culture, thus making it difficult to build European nationality. From the specifics and reasons listed above, it is usually concluded that European citizenship is usually impossible.


Taking the current status from the development of European nations into account, it is risky for an individual country to build up all alone.  In the circumstance of the global market, a ecu country would appear so poor in rivalling with other economical powers like the United States. It seems an inescapable trend for European international locations to unite together to compete with other folks. First of all, the most important task should be to circulate an individual currency within European international locations. In addition , Western social incorporation is necessary even though the fact continues to be that it is continue to impossible currently. Taking every one of the factors which contribute to the impracticality of the organization of European citizenship into mind, it seems in my opinion that the interpersonal integration of Europe is considered the most significant 1. Despite the fact that up to the present, Euro social the use seems infeasible due to the explanation that there exists great curve in European societies, it is far from assumed which the only requirement for the European incorporation is the full convergence in social, cost effective, and politics aspects of European countries. Switzerland as well as the United States could be taken as a good example of fully developed social integration of many several cultures and ethnic organizations. It should be remarked that there exists common shared personal as well as social bonds in these societies. Furthermore, these societies”possess a strong socio-political consensus” (Sobisch& Immerfall, 1997), which is just what is lacking in Euro societies.


Davies, I. (1997). Education pertaining to European Nationality: Review of Relevant Documentation. In I. Davies & A. Sobisch (Eds. ), Expanding European Individuals (pp. 97-120). Sheffield, UK: Sheffield Hallam University Press. Dell’olio, F. (2005). The Europeanization of citizenship: involving the ideology of nationality, migration and Western european identity. Burlington, US: Ashgate Publishing Business. Deflem, Meters., & Pampel, F. C. (1996). The parable of postnational identity: well-known support pertaining to European concentration. Social Forces, 75(1), 119-143. Eder, E., & Giesen, B. (Eds. ) (2003). European nationality: between countrywide legacies and postnational projects. New York, US: Oxford University Press. Schlesinger, P. (1987). On countrywide identity: several conceptions and misconceptions criticized. Social Scientific research Information, 26(2), 219-264. doi: 10. 1177/053901887026002001 Scully, R. (1997). Producing European Establishments: Governing Western european Integration. In I.

Davies & A. Sobisch (Eds. ), Developing Euro Citizens (pp. 51-72). Sheffield, UK: Sheffield Hallam College or university Press. Sobisch, A., & Immerfall, S i9000. (1997). The Social Basis of European Citizenship. In We. Davies & A. Sobisch (Eds. ), Developing Western european Citizens (pp. 141-174). Sheffield, UK: Sheffield Hallam College or university Press. Sobisch, A. (1997). The European Union and European Nationality. In I. Davies & A. Sobisch (Eds. ), Developing Euro Citizens (pp. 73-96). Sheffield, UK: Sheffield Hallam University Press. Sobisch, A. (1997). Interest In, Understanding of, and Support For the European Union. In I actually. Davies & A. Sobisch (Eds. ), Developing European Citizens (pp. 123-140). Sheffield, UK: Sheffield Hallam University or college Press. Wiener, A. (1998). “European” nationality practice: building institutions of any non-state. Canadian Journal of political scientific research, 32(3), 603-605. doi: 12. 1017/S0008423900014189


< Prev post Next post >
Category: Essay,

Topic: Western european,

Words: 4742

Published: 04.02.20

Views: 90