Home » education » notebook computers replace textbook essay

Notebook computers replace textbook essay

The initial a reaction to this query by many persons is, “What a silly question! ” However , there are many key issues to consider, like expense, ease of use (is the computer screen too hard in our eye for considerable reading? ), maintenance and repair (if students take them coming from class to class, can they break? ), although most importantly, college student learning (what is the best method to help college students learn? ). In order to arrive to a realization on the subject, all these issues must be explored.


First let’s look at price. Publishers can create a CD with their textbooks, with a greatly reduced price since there is no need for conventional paper, printing and binding. Though the costs can be spread to the purchasers in other ways. The need for the technology to use the CDs is a largest expenditure. However , the majority of districts spend money on technology previously, and with the acquiring a notebook computer for each pupil, the need for laptop labs ought to eventually turn into minimal or obsolete as laptops are ordered.

This should be regarded as when looking at costs of purchasing notebook computers and text message CDs. Another side effect of giving, hiring or demanding student getting laptops is that other computer functions just like word control and PowerPoint should be added with the initial purchase, and all students will have related ability to get programs to complete research assignments. Reading a computer screen can be challenging for extended expanses of text, so I think that the expense of printing kept by the web publishers will be given to to the owner of the printing device to which college student computers are connected, although cost will probably be considerably lower than binding a textbook.

A few students is probably not organized in keeping webpages in order, or throw away the chapters when they are done, so in the event that students wish to refer for the book down the road, they may find a need to reprint parts of the book.

Conventional paper will unavoidably be squandered. The actual price difference may be hard to discern, but it really is likely that a laptop with digital text mixture, in the end, are more expensive. The question is, exactly what the focus of the school district? Should certainly school schisme sacrifice scholar learning in the interest of a cost savings? Some laptop companies provide special courses

or quantity savings. Some schisme may require parents to purchase laptop computers. Henrico Region Public Colleges in ia, offers insurance on notebooks, which the college system possesses, to father and mother for $50.

Tracy Specific School Area in Washington dc at all their charter school, Discovery Rental School, has implemented a laptop program, and substituted their textbooks with notebooks for twenty percent more than the cost of textbooks. They expect the cost to decrease because, in the future, they are only going to need to exchange laptops which have been broken, and buy new disks for their books

Ease of use

Next, consider ease of use. If a school may hook up a wireless network, pupils should be able to get online resources from the majority of places inside the school, which includes study corridor. Teachers should no longer listen to that pupils could not enter into the catalogue or laboratory to total assignments, and students will be free to explore the ability from the technology even more completely.

Actually teachers could find themselves changing their way of teaching to best utilize technology. Educational institutions that apply a notebook program should employ technology people to train students and teachers using them, to take care of the equipment, as well as continue to keep networks as a way. This is very important to help minimize stress on the part of college students and professors. It is very irritating to have a lessons planned rather than be able to go forward because issues out of your control are generally not working properly.

Student learning

Scholar learning is the central thing to consider when deciding instructing methods. Laptops allow for even more interactivity with subjects by using multimedia strategies. Publishers Holt, Rinehart and Winston present concepts just like photosynthesis applying animation which enhances printed words about them. Students also can reach WebQuests and other ruse such as frog dissections on the Internet. Students can generate projects employing PowerPoint and many other programs to illustrate the actual have learned. Each one of these things support a constructivist atmosphere which has been shown to enhance learning.

Advantages and disadvantages

A good way to examine the question is to create a list of pros and cons on the subject. Inside the category of positives:

The ability to change outdated and incorrect data quickly and inexpensively.

Laptop literacy, that can be important inside the job universe, becomes a habit to students who have frequent access to a pc.

Interactivity is enhanced with laptops and a constructivist atmosphere is definitely fostered.

Usage of laptops enable a student led atmosphere by simply instituting an even more project-based method of learning, likewise promoting a constructivist ambiance.

Concepts are easier to grasp once presented within a multimedia approach.

A notebook for each college student builds a bridge across the digital separate.

Giving learners an expensive unit encourages responsibility for the gear.

Many learners and teachers who have been component to laptop programs in schools report increased organization functionality.

Students may “trade” areas with educators, offering new information that was not proven to the tutor or school, fostering a feeling of pride and self-esteem.

A few texts provide students the cabability to highlight and annotate although studying.

Teachers in notebook schools record that learners create much longer and more well crafted assignments mainly because they need not really use useful resource books to discover

transliteration and sentence structure mistakes. Pupils report that they learn about composing styles better because of the instant corrections.

In case the district uses digital text messages, students will not likely need to carry huge and heavy books from class to school. Backpacks will probably be lighter and damage to spines will be less likely. Students also may need to dedicate less time inside their lockers. The cons are not as numerous, although contain more “weighty” products:

The possibility of robbery (will the laptops generate students a target? )

Breakage and maintenance are costly and can trigger students to shed time about projects.

The laptops themselves are expensive, although some vendors offer huge special discounts to colleges and for quantities purchased.

We have a need to have a fantastic connection to the net, preferably an invisible one.

The teachers should be on board, or perhaps they will not use the laptops plus the resource will probably be wasted (and the money spent will be wasted).

Stealing subjects is a higher temptation with easier a connection to the internet.

Students could become distracted and get off activity more easily.

Technology failure, of types.

Actually on a review given to teachers at Piscataquis Community High school graduation in Maine on their One-to-One Laptop Plan, there were only three primary complaints following two years of involvement inside the program: 1) Laptops leading to distractions, 2) inappropriate usage of the computers, and 3) technology failure.

One point of view to consider is that the moment school zones buy books, students include a few activities they can complete using them. They will read and study to learn. They may locate practice quizzes and further solutions in books but they need to take the initiative to go to the library, or search for information, and grade their quizzes.

The functions of your textbook happen to be few, although important. Each time a school areas buys a laptop and digital details for a pupil, the student finds him/herself in a position to not only go through and research to learn, although able to totally synthesize the information with fun quizzes, and links for additional information, and an capability to produce a conventional paper or other end product. Students will not have to have a computer in the home, or go to a public selection or pc lab to complete their assignments.

Too, all pupils will be making use of the same courses. The most valuable places to find information about notebook programs is from schools that have executed them for 3 years or even more, so the Hawthorne affect offers diminished, seeing that most of them have been in the news, studied or scrutinized in some way. Likewise by then, the novelty of using new-technology, which can inspire students to examine more, has worn off. In Maine, standardised test scores for eighth graders have been completely only a bit elevated or the same over non-laptop educational institutions.

In an document by Andrew Speyer named “Technology in Schools: How come Laptops? “, Mr. Speyer states that “A notebook computer in a class will not lead to students having higher SEATED scores. You will not regret guarantee that learners will have bigger grades, better attention, or learn the daily material more completely… Control will change from a teacher-based knowledge to a collaborative experience. If you have any single argument when you use laptops within a classroom this may be it. ” Even with no significant improvement in ratings, laptops are still worth having because they support constructivist methods, which has been shown to improve learning.

In fact , the question that arises in the newest literature is not “Should universities use notebook compters? “, yet “Can hands helds replace laptops? “


Laptops should not only replace textbooks, yet can enhance student learning overall. Applying computers on the consistent basis can push a classroom toward a much more collaborative approach to learning. With laptops pupils would be able to have access to the Internet for study, word digesting, and PowerPoint programs whenever, even in study lounge.

If a college district usually takes the money they might normally spend on textbooks and add some of their technology money, they are often able to acquire a goal of providing a laptop for each scholar over time. Whether or not standardized test scores remain the same, there are still advantages to having a laptop computer for each pupil.

Regular Male impotence students publish longer, more complete tasks, possibly because of ease the of applying word control and better resource looking ability. Shopping for laptops and digital books may be an enormous step for taking, but a district may be able to function their method into them slowly by introducing laptop computers a grade level each time, or in several other ways. If the goal of the district is to maximize student learning, person laptops might be a good way to take action. Laptop learning supports constructivist activities, which were shown to increase learning.

Activities which learners have a say in choosing on their own, and picking their own methods to complete, allow them to become more fervent and included in their learning. They can become more like partners in their personal learning, instead of fairly sedentary absorbers. Using a laptop a total project can be accomplished, but with a textbook, only half of a project can be accomplished.

PUBLISHER: Alisa Humphrey


Curtis, D. (2003, December 16). The Maine Event. Edutopia Online. Recovered October twelve, 2004 via http://www.glef.org/php/article.php?id=Art_1119. Chapman, G. (1998, June 15). Push to trade course textbooks intended for laptop Personal computers is a wrong use of technology. Los Angeles Instances. Retrieved March 6, 2005 from http://www.utexas.edu/lbj/21cp/laptops.htm. Cook, G. (2002, July). Laptop Learning. ASJB. com. 189 (7). Retrieved Oct 9, 2005 from http://www.asbj.com/2002/07/0702coverstory.html. Harris, Walt J. & Smith, Lori. (February 2004). Laptop employ by 7th grade learners with problems: Perceptions of special education teachers. Maine Education


You may also be interested in this: describe a laptop, describe laptop


< Prev post Next post >
Category: Education,

Topic: College student, College students, Student learning,

Words: 2057

Published: 03.02.20

Views: 486